Published by the Jewish Bible Association · Jerusalem
ISSN 0792-3910Subscribe
Jewish Bible Quarterly
The only Jewish-sponsored English-language journal devoted exclusively to the Bible · Est. 1972
← Back to Vol. 36:1 contents
Vol. 36:1 · January – March 2008

Ha'achashtranim Bnei Ha'ramachim

Translating Esther 8:10
Zvi Ron
pp. 33–38·6 pages
Abstract

Surveys the long history of rabbinic and scholarly attempts to translate the notoriously obscure phrase ha'achashtranim bnei ha'ramachim in Esther 8:10 - a phrase the Talmud itself calls untranslatable - covering readings that identify the animals as mules, horses, camels, riders, or runners, an eight-legged folkloric creature, and the modern Persian-derived understanding of achashtranim as 'royal' steeds.

Ron traces the interpretive history of ha’achashtranim bnei ha’ramachim, a phrase in Esther 8:10 that the Talmud (Megilla 18a) itself declares beyond translation. Saadia Gaon and later commentators read achashtranim as mules bred of mares, prized for their strength or lineage; other sources understand ramachim as the riders rather than the animals, or as “runners” whose spleens were surgically removed for speed, following a description of King David’s son Adonijah’s couriers. Rashi instead reads achashtranim as a swift breed of camel. One medieval commentator even describes an eight-legged folkloric steed drawn from European legend. Modern scholarship derives achashtranim from the Persian khshatra, “royal,” yielding a sense close to “the king’s own swift horses” - confirming that whatever its precise referent, the phrase conveys the extraordinary speed with which Ahasuerus’s decree was disseminated.

About the Author
Zvi Ron

Zvi Ron was ordained by the Chief Rabbinate of Israel and is the rabbi emeritus of Keneseth Beth Israel in Richmond, Virginia. He currently teaches in Jerusalem.

Cite this article
Chicago

Zvi Ron. "Ha'achashtranim Bnei Ha'ramachim." Jewish Bible Quarterly 36, no. 1 (January – March 2008): 33–38.

MLA

Zvi Ron. "Ha'achashtranim Bnei Ha'ramachim." Jewish Bible Quarterly, vol. 36, no. 1, 2008, pp. 33–38.

← Previous
Who Counted Righteousness to Whom?