Published by the Jewish Bible Association · Jerusalem
ISSN 0792-3910Subscribe
Jewish Bible Quarterly
The only Jewish-sponsored English-language journal devoted exclusively to the Bible · Est. 1972
← Back to Vol. 36:1 contents
Vol. 36:1 · January – March 2008

"There Is No Chronological Order in the Torah"

An Axiom for Understanding the Book of Joshua
Hayyim Angel
pp. 3–11·9 pages
Abstract

Applies the rabbinic axiom that the Torah's narratives are not always in chronological sequence to the Book of Joshua, arguing that departures from historical order in Chapters 1-2, the covenant ceremony at Gerizim and Ebal, and the placement of Chapter 24 at the Book's close are deliberate literary choices that highlight Joshua's initial fear, the nation's growing initiative, and the unique freewill covenant that concludes the Book.

Angel applies the rabbinic principle that “there is no chronological order in the Torah” to the Book of Joshua, examining three major departures from historical sequence: the placement of the spies’ mission (Chapter 2) after Joshua’s exhortation to the tribes (Chapter 1), the uncertain timing of the covenant ceremony at Mount Gerizim and Mount Ebal (8:30-35), and the positioning of Joshua’s freewill covenant at Shechem (Chapter 24) after his farewell address (Chapter 23). He argues each rearrangement serves a literary purpose: Chapters 1-2 highlight Joshua’s initial lack of confidence balanced against the nation’s growing initiative; the Gerizim-Ebal ceremony, likely conducted earlier than its placement suggests, stresses that observance of the Torah must anchor the conquest; and Chapter 24’s climactic position emphasizes the unique freewill nature of the covenant Joshua secures, in contrast to the original covenant given directly by God at Sinai.

About the Author
Hayyim Angel

Hayyim Angel is Rabbi at Congregation Shearith Israel of New York City (the Spanish-Portuguese Synagogue, founded in 1654) and teaches Tanakh at Yeshiva University. Twenty of his biblical studies were published as a book, entitled Through an Opaque Lens.

Cite this article
Chicago

Hayyim Angel. ""There Is No Chronological Order in the Torah"." Jewish Bible Quarterly 36, no. 1 (January – March 2008): 3–11.

MLA

Hayyim Angel. ""There Is No Chronological Order in the Torah"." Jewish Bible Quarterly, vol. 36, no. 1, 2008, pp. 3–11.